Golden Sun Hacking Community

Which do like best?

Before I vote... What are they?

Have a nice day.

Mudshipping is a romantic fanfic about isaac and Mia.
Valeshipping is a romantic fanfic about isaac and jenna.

I'm not a fan of shipping myself...but i'd have to choose mudshipping.

I noticed the only name you capitalized was Mia's... I assume that means you like Mia better than the other characters?

I don't like either (DUDE IT'S ALL ABOUT CLOSETSHIPPING THESE DAYS), but the more plausible one is most likely Valeshipping.

/defend

Pffft.  EVERYONE knows that Sol Harem shipping is where it's at.

Hm... Well, I think that they both seem kind of odd, but I chose Isaac to be with Jenna.

Have a nice day.

RAWRZ!

FOOLISH VALESHIPPERS!

Now, come on. If this is really just a Valeshipping bash thread, that's fine. If that's the way your going to be, then *snap*

Oh my, did Jenna just lock this?

Hmm...Mia and Isaac doesn't make much sense to me. Valeshipping definitely.

Neither of them make any sense. GS was very lacking on Character Development.
The only canon pairing is Weirdshipping [one-sided] and that Kushinada one in Izumo.

Actually Valeshipping does have some sense. Remember the conversation with the mayor of Mafra after retrieving the Black Orb where he gives the party the Cyclone Chip? Sheba talks about Isaac and makes Jenna blush...Nothing special but it's something right?

I personally prefer Valeshipping, but Mudshipping has some basis too, if you Mind Read some of the residents of Vale in the first game, someone's thinking "Looks like Isaac found another pretty girl. I wonder what Jenna will think when she sees this?"

Oh, well I only played the first golden sun once so I don't know about the details on it. But what you said pretty much serves as basis for both Vale and Mudshipping.

Off-Topic: Congrats on your 200th post Jamie!

I do not really know which to choice, but they both have their ups and downs.

Mudshipping might be the more likely one, but....

:Isaac: :Mia: :Jenna:

Jenna: Hello, what are you two doing?

Like I said...

:Isaac: x :Jenna: x :Sheba: x :Mia:

Now everybody is happy.

That seems a bit odd...

So, we have Valeshipping.

:Isaac: :Jenna:

Mudshipping...

:Isaac: :Mia:

What about Dustshipping?

:Isaac: :Sheba:

Or Asexualshipping?

:Isaac: :Isaac:

Hm... I go with Asexualshipping, where Isaac makes a genetic clone of himself.

Have a nice day.

Dustshipping would be Felix and Sheba...
Hmm....Asexualshipping for Isaac seems to be right.  :Sweat: xD

:Felix: x :Sheba: has a different ship name, IIRC...

I'm not an expert in this Shipping thing so I went researching about it...
And, well, in case anyone wants no know more, here's a link: http://goldensun.wikia.com/wiki/Shipping

There's a LOT more than that, actually, those are just the most well known ones.  Like my parody, Sol Harem, already posted in one of its many varieties.

Some of them are really...randomly strange...  :um: :Sweat:
Sol Harem? And where can I find it, if you don't mind telling me?

Sol Harem shipping:  Any Venus Adept x Any Mars Adept x Any Jupiter Adept x Any Mercury Adept

Basically, one member of each element present, all paired together in one big harem, thus: Sol Harem.  For example, it could be...

:Isaac: x :Jenna: x :Sheba: x :Mia:

OR

:Felix: x :Garet: x :Ivan: x :Piers:

OR

:Kushinada: x : Karst: x :Feizhi: x :Mia:

OR

:Felix: x :Jenna: x :Maha: x :Alex:

So long as you have one (and ONLY ONE) member of each element, you qualify!

Also, Charon, Atrius, could y'all restore the emotes of the old forums, and if y'all could have them be a standard size while you're at it.  For the characters and djinn, perhaps we should stick to the game's 32x32 pic size, for instance?  The emote balloons were 16x16, and the bullets should stay as they are...

Oh, I see.
Thank you for explaining Role.

:Jupiter: :Sheba: :Felix: = Lighthouseshipping/Sandshipping/Catfoodshipping[/Dustshipping???] = FTW
:Isaac: :Jenna: is my vote. Because I played GS:TLA before GS:1 :JupiterDjinni:

Yeah, the reason why I paired  :Isaac: +  :Sheba: for Dustshipping instead of  :Felix: +  :Sheba: was because these two already have a name...

Er, Role? How does that Sol Harem Shipping work between  :Felix: :Garet: :Ivan: :Piers:??? Doesn't there have to be at least one girl to count? Wait, oops, sorry for my error, I forgot about Garet.

Have a nice day.

You also forgot Piers.

I still vote :Isaac:+ :Jenna: and :Garet:+ :Sheba:.

Yeah, but last time I checked, robots could not reproduce. Also, if they rarely have children in Lemuria, well then... I suppose they must get old very quickly then.

Have a nice day.

Oh yeah, forgot about the fact that he's a robot...

Yeah. So, Garet is a crossdresser (she sure fooled us all), and Piers is a robot.

Anyway, I still vote for dustshipping.

:Isaac: + :Sheba:

Or... Well, everyone knows who has the most personality, right?

:VenusDjinni:

So, how about Plantshipping?

:VenusDjinni: + Briggs

This way, we should be (almost) guaranteed the most interesting character. Of course, I do not know the mechanics of two different species crossing, but it would be worth it.

Have a nice day.

steamshipping is my vote

Quote from: Salanewt on 06, November, 2009, 10:51:34 PM
Yeah, the reason why I paired  :Isaac: +  :Sheba: for Dustshipping instead of  :Felix: +  :Sheba: was because these two already have a name...

Er, Role? How does that Sol Harem Shipping work between  :Felix: :Garet: :Ivan: :Piers:??? Doesn't there have to be at least one girl to count? Wait, oops, sorry for my error, I forgot about Garet.

Have a nice day.

...You mean to tell me you've never heard of Yaoi?

nope, never

Allow me to raep your brain then:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yaoi

Don't forget the brain bleach when you leave, those rabid Yaoi fangirls really mess you up when you stray too close.

Ew! Besides, how can it be their fantasy if they can't-never mind. Instead of being wrapped in extra plastic, they should be padlocked and placed in a safe under the ocean. The scary part is that if a parent picks that up, thinking that it is just cartoons without reading it, then... Ew!

Have a nice day.

Edit: But... Although this Yaoi-shipping is an odd thing to think about, it would be impossible for them to have kids unless one of them is composed of 2 genders (or is actually a female).

So?  Shipping is just romantic, it has nothing to do with kids.  I included one that was Het, one that was Yaoi, one that was Yuri, and one that mixed a bit of Incest and Bestiality in the mix.  The point was, it doesn't matter what the end is like, so long as you have one adept of each element getting busy all with one another.  No matter how F***ed up the members are, so long as it's one Venus, one Mars, one Jupiter, and one Mercury, it qualifies.

Oh, it is? I assumed that the "shipping" was for having kids because they, er... "Set sail".

Have a nice day.

How about emotionshipping?

:heart: + :Sweat:
           =
:um:    +  :fury:

RelationSHIPing.

Yeah, I realize that now.

Okay then... How about Demonshipping?

Any combination of human with djinni, or djinni with djinni.

:Piers: :MercurySet:
or
:MercurySet: :MercuryDjinni:
or
:Mia: :MercurySet:

Would all be something like this... Or is there already a name for it (technically, I do not consider djinni animals, or else it would be beastiality (multiple ways to spell it, but it is sick :irate:)).

Have a nice day.

Djinnshipping is Flint x Mist (or whatever djinni Mia came with), iirc.

True, but how about with any djinni, not just those two?

Have a nice day.
:MercuryDjinni: :MercurySet:

How should I know?  Besides, we're going way off topic, since this is a discussion about Valeshipping vs Mudshipping...  I really don't care, which is why I parodied the shipping war with my 'preferred' shipping - Sol Harem.

omigod you mentioned yaoi oh crap my mind my mind my mind it buuuuuurrrrrns

*purges*

Alright. I'm feeling better.

I personally feel the two ships are far overdone. Everyone knows it's about Magmashipping these days, seriously.

The fools didn't know what it was.  I warned people to grab their brain bleach.

Yeah... After all, I suppose a link and a warning is better than an accidental find when searching on the Internet.

And yes, I suppose we are off topic, but don't forget that the poll had an "Other" option.

I find that relationships in Golden Sun are rarely cut out clearly enough (other than Isaac with Jenna). Besides, the line that the lady said in Vale could have meant something like "Uh-oh, Isaac has a new female friend, will Jenna be jealous?", despite the words being different.

Have a nice day.

Not even Isaac x Jenna has much going for it, other than a one-sided crush that's only hinted about.  For all we know, Isaac could just see her as a friend.  There's just not enough info to say for certain, which is why there's so many ships for GS.  There's as much evidence for Isaac x Piers as there is Isaac x Jenna.  Heck, Sheba could have just said that to pester and annoy her.

This is true. I will never forget Jenna blushing like she did though, and Mia said "Isaac has been worried sick about you" (even though he never said anything about Jenna in the first game... (_ _ all)). I suppose there is almost as much evidence for Isaac and Piers, but I would think that Felix and Piers is a bit more likely...

Piers: I'm a water adept, so I'm coming with you Felix... (I forget the exact words).

More like...

Piers: Even though I am the only one who can naturally use ply, and would probably be better to stay here to help heal Isaac and Ivan, I really want to go with you.  :happy:

Felix:  :?:

Piers: I also have water psynergy, which will help against-KARST DOES NOT COMPUTE

DOES NOT COMPUTE-Machineshipping might be better! Piers and Shaman leader... Both have the least developed personalities.

I vote for Machineshipping, lol.

Have a nice day.

Other,  :Jenna: +  :Isaac:'s dad

QuoteMachineshipping

Robotshipping

Isaac + Pier's daughter or mother.

Valeshipping, definitely. Alsoalso, Garet x Sheba. Not that they're perfect for each other or anything, but just that it's practically canon.

Quote from: GS:TLA endingSheba: "Aw... Poor baby."
Jenna: "What's wrong with you? How could you say that to Garet?"
Mia: "Tee hee. I wonder...."

QuoteMachineshipping

Felix/Piers. For some odd reason, there are TONS of Felix/Piers fanfics out there.

Valeshipping is canon, Matthew is the child.

[/topic]

I do not understand how that should end the topic, since the original poll was just asking us which of the two we prefer, and then we can talk about others we like.

Have a nice day.